Dental Evidence as a Sole Human Identifier in World Disasters: A Literature Review with Emphasis on the 2004 Tsunami Disaster
محتوى المقال
الملخص
Comparative dental analysis is a quick and relatively simple human identification method. In many disaster incidents, dental characteristics have played an important role in establishing the identity of victims when they were visually unidentifiable. A PubMed search was conducted for publications that specifically discussed the role of dental characteristics in Disaster Victim Identification (DVI). Between 1974 and 2012, 14 papers described 17 disasters in which dental characteristics were used to identify the victims. The percentage of victims identified using only dental characteristics ranged from 0% to 89%. This wide range largely depends on the availability and quality of ante mortem dental records provided by dentists. The DVI in Thailand following the Indian Ocean tsunami in December 2004 was unique in involving deceased tourists from more than 30 countries, mostly from Europe. The dental method of identification showed superiority over other identification methods in terms of speed and accuracy of establishing the victims’ identity. This paper discusses the role of forensic odontology in establishing the identity of disaster victims, with specific emphasis on the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami as an example of good practice, during which the author had first-hand experience.
الكلمات المفتاحية
Forensic Sciences، Forensic Odontology، Disaster Victim Identification، Dental Characteristics
التنزيلات
المراجع
Disaster Victim Identification guide 2014. Lyon, Interpol;
(http://www.interpol.int/INTERPOL-expertise/
Forensics/DVI-Pages/DVI-guide)
Reesu GV, Augustine J, Urs AB. Forensic considerations
when dealing with incinerated human dental remains.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2015; 29:13-7. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.jflm.2014.10.006, PMid:25572078
Bose RS, Mohan B, Lakshminarayanan L. Effects of
elevated temperatures on various restorative materials:
an in vitro study. Indian J Dent Res. 2005;16(2):56-60.
PMid:16372794
Madi HA, Swaid S, Al-Amad S. Assessment of the
uniqueness of human dentition. J Forensic Odontostomatol.
;31(1):30-9. PMid:24776439
Pretty IA, Sweet D. A look at forensic dentistry--Part
: The role of teeth in the determination of human
identity. Br Dent J. 2001;190(7):359-66. https://doi.
org/10.1038/sj.bdj.4800972a, https://doi.org/10.1038/
sj.bdj.4800972
Leeuw W. Maintaining proper dental records. Dental Assistant,
, 83(2):22-3, 26-30, 32-4. PMid:24834675
Brown L. Inadequate record keeping by dental practitioners.
Aust Dent J. 2015;60(4):497-502. https://doi.
org/10.1111/adj.12258, PMid:25431111
McAndrew R, Ban J, Playle R. A comparison of computer-
and hand-generated clinical dental notes with
statutory regulations in record keeping. Eur J Dent
Educ. 2012; 16(1):e117-21. https://doi.org/10.1111/
j.1600-0579.2011.00684.x, PMid:22251334
Kieser JA, Laing W, Herbison P. Lessons learned
from large-scale comparative dental analysis following
the South Asian tsunami of 2004. J Forensic Sci.
; 51(1):109-12. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1556-
2005.00012.x, PMid:16423233
Kogon S, Banting DW, Sandhu H. Foreign-trained
dentists’ perceived knowledge and skills after graduation
from a structured two-year program. J Dent Educ.
; 75(8):1098-106. PMid:21828304
Chong JA, Chew JK, Ravindranath S, Pau A. Clinical
audit teaching in record-keeping for dental undergraduates
at International Medical University, Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia. J Dent Educ. 2014; 78(2):206-12.
PMid:24489028
Dierickx A, Seyler M, de Valck E, Wijffels J, Willems
G. Dental records: a Belgium study. J Forensic Odontostomatol.
;24(1):22-31. PMid:16783953
Dumancić J, Kaić Z, Njemirovskij V, Brkić H, Zecević
D.Dental identification after two mass disasters in Croatia.
Croat Med J. 2001;42(6):657-62. PMid:11740850
Moody GH, Busuttil A. Identification in the Lockerbie
air disaster. Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 1994;15(1):63-
https://doi.org/10.1097/00000433-199403000-
, PMid:8166119
Obafunwa JO, Ogunbanjo VO, Ogunbanjo OB, Soyemi
SS, Faduyile FA. Forensic odontological observations
in the victims of DANA air crash. Pan Afr Med J.
;20:96. PMid:26213597 PMCid:PMC4506801
Nambiar P, Jalil N, Singh B. The dental identification
of victims of an aircraft accident in Malaysia. Int Dent
J. 1997;47(1):9-15. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1875-
X.1997.tb00671.x, PMid:9448783
Brkic H, Strinovic D, Kubat M, Petrovecki V. Odontological
identification of human remains from mass
graves in Croatia. Int J Legal Med. 2000;114(1-
:19-22. https://doi.org/10.1007/s004149900130,
PMid:11197622
Trengrove H. Operation earthquake 2011: Christchurch
earthquake disaster victim identification. J Forensic
Odontostomatol. 2011;29(2):1-7. PMid:22717907
Ligthelm AJ. The Helderberg air disaster forensic
odontological investigations. J Forensic Odontostomatol.
;12(1):15-8. PMid:9227085
Hinchliffe J. Forensic odontology, part 3. The Australian
bushfires - Victoria state, February 2009. Br
Dent J. 2011;210(7):317-21. https://doi.org/10.1038/
sj.bdj.2011.239, PMid:21475281
Bassed R. Forensic Odontology in the Aftermath of the
Australian Bush Fires. Proceedings of the American
Academy of Forensic Sciences. Annual Scientific
Meeting Seattle, February, 2010. Page 270. Can be accessed
at: https://www.aafs.org/wp-content/uploads/
ProceedingsSeattle2010Rev07-24-12.pdf
Hutt JM1, Ludes B, Kaess B, Tracqui A, Mangin P.
Odontological identification of the victims of flight
AI. IT 5148 air disaster Lyon-Strasbourg 20.01.1992.
Int J Legal Med. 1995;107(6):275-9. https://doi.
org/10.1007/BF01246872, PMid:7577688
Martin-de las Heras S, Valenzuela A, Villanueva E,
Marques T, Exposito N, Bohoyo JM. Methods for
identification of 28 burn victims following a 1996 bus
accident in Spain. J Forensic Sci. 1999;44(2):428-31.
https://doi.org/10.1520/JFS14480J
Soomer H, Ranta H, Penttilä A. Identification of victims
from the M/S Estonia. Int J Legal Med. 2001;114(4-
:259-62. https://doi.org/10.1007/s004140000180,
PMid:11355406
Solheim T, Lorentsen M, Sundnes PK, Bang G,
Bremnes L. The “Scandinavian Star” ferry disaster
- a challenge to forensic odontology. Int J Legal
Med. 1992;104(6):339-45. https://doi.org/10.1007/
BF01369554, PMid:1515361
Valenzuela A, Marques T, Exposito N, Martín-De Las
Heras S, García G. Comparative study of efficiency
of dental methods for identification of burn victims in
two bus accidents in Spain. Am J Forensic Med Pathol.
;23(4):390-3. https://doi.org/10.1097/00000433-
-00019, PMid:12464820
Stene-Johansen W, Solheim T, Sakshaug O. Dental
identification after the Dash 7 aircraft accident at
Torghatten, Northern Norway, May 6th, 1988. J Forensic
Odontostomatol. 1992;10(1):15-24. PMid:1429934
Tibballs G. Tsunami: The Most Terrifying Disaster.
Carlton Publishing Group; 1st edition, 2005.
PMCid:PMC1720176
Danschutter DR. Tsunami: response to a disaster.
Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America,
,17(4):481-94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
ccell.2005.08.005, PMid:16344216
Merriam-Webster online dictionary; 2015 (http://www.
merriam-webster.com/dictionary/tsunami)
Brenner CH. Some mathematical problems in the
DNA identification of victims in the 2004 tsunami
and similar mass fatalities. Forensic Science International,
,157:172–180. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
forsciint.2005.11.003, PMid:16361074
Morgan OW, Sribanditmongkol P, Perera C, Sulasmi Y,
Van Alphen D, Sondorp E. Mass fatality management
following the South Asian tsunami disaster: case studies
in Thailand, Indonesia, and Sri Lanka. PLoS Medicine,
, 3(6):e195. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.
pmed.0030195, PMid:16737348 PMCid:PMC1472696
James H. Thai tsunami victim identification overview
to date. Journal of Forensic Odontostomatology, 2005,
(1):1-18.
United Nations News Centre. UN launches unprecedented
multiple effort to aid victims of Asia’s devastating
tsunami; 2004. http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.
asp?NewsID=12914#.VM3wjMbYn8k).
Andersen Torpet L. DVI System International: software
assisting in the Thai tsunami victim identification process.
J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2005; 23(1):19-25.
PMid:16223022
Schuller-Götzburg P, Suchanek J. Forensic odontologists
successfully identify tsunami victims in Phuket,
Thailand. Forensic Sci Int. 2007; 171(2-3):204-
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2006.08.013,
PMid:17029859
Petju M, Suteerayongprasert A, Thongpud R, Hassiri
K. Importance of dental records for victim identification
following the Indian Ocean tsunami disaster
in Thailand. Public Health. 2007;121(4):251-7. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.puhe.2006.12.003, PMid:17276465
Al-Amad S, McCullough M, Graham J, Clement J, Hill
A. Craniofacial identification by computer-mediated
superimposition. J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2006,
(2):47-52. PMid:17175836